Garmin CIRQA Ultimate Scientific Review!
wearablesfitness-trackergarminheart-ratesleep-trackinghrvscientific-testingproduct-review
Verdict: recommended-on-biceps
TL;DR
- Rob (The Quantified Scientist) systematically tested the Garmin CIRQA smart band against a Polar H10 ECG chest strap (exercise HR) and a ZMax EEG headband (sleep stages), worn both on the wrist and on the biceps. Placement moved the results more than anything else.
- On the biceps the CIRQA is one of the best HR trackers he's tested: correlations of 1.00 (spinning), 0.96 (biking), 0.98 (running), 0.91 (weightlifting) โ HR score 98/100, rated "great." On the wrist it drops to 93/100 ("good"), with running the weak spot at 0.89 (better than only 27% of tested devices).
- Sleep stage tracking was unexpectedly better on the biceps too: deep sleep agreement 91% vs 81%, REM 58% vs 45% โ sleep score 73 (biceps, "good") vs 64 (wrist, "okay"/third tier). Rob can't fully explain it โ possibly a cleaner optical signal with fewer motion artifacts on the upper arm, possibly chance from limited nights.
- Nightly heart rate and HRV are accurate at both wearing positions; the physical button is a big quality-of-life win over the hit-and-miss automatic activity detection.
- Verdict: recommended, but wear it on the biceps for exercise. Caveats: the official biceps band is ~โฌ60 and slow to ship, the red colorway looks like a faded pink in person, and the Fitbit Air / Amazfit Helios strap offer comparable performance for $99.
Key moments
- [00:00] Cold-open hook โ Rob holds both CIRQA boxes to camera (frame_0001.jpg) and states the test plan: exercise HR, nighttime metrics, sleep stages, wrist vs biceps.
- [01:07] Colorway warning โ the reddish CIRQA looks like a faded pink in person, very different from the box (frame_0011.jpg shows the unboxing B-roll).
- [01:53] Methodology โ reference devices explained: Polar H10 ECG chest strap for exercise HR, plotted as wrist-left / biceps-right scatter plots (frame_0015.jpg).
- [02:18-07:45] Exercise HR results โ spinning 0.99/1.00, running 0.89/0.98, biking 0.92/0.96, weightlifting 0.73/0.91 (wrist/biceps). Wrist running showed phantom HR spikes.
- [08:26] Competition percentiles โ wrist placement beats only 27% of tested devices for running; biceps placement beats 63-77% across exercises.
- [09:52] HR scores โ biceps 98 ("great") vs wrist 93 ("good"), shown in Rob's spreadsheet (frame_0016.jpg).
- [10:34] Sponsor/support break โ affiliate links pitch, with editor Alex credited (frame_0017.jpg).
- [11:22] Sleep methodology โ ZMax EEG headband as "silver standard" reference (frame_0027.jpg shows the EEG rig; frame_0028.jpg the sleeping setup).
- [12:33] The surprise โ biceps sleep staging beats wrist: deep 91% vs 81%, REM 58% vs 45% (agreement matrix in frame_0025.jpg); Rob offers two theories at [15:48]: cleaner signal vs small-sample chance.
- [17:26] Sleep-tracker tier list โ first tier: Apple Watch, Pixel Watch, Fitbit, Whoop, Oura Ring 4, Eight Sleep Pod (frame_0038.jpg); CIRQA-on-biceps lands second tier, wrist third tier.
- [21:35] Verdict โ button praised, auto activity detection criticized; final advice: biceps for exercise, wrist at night is fine if you don't care about sleep stages ([23:30]); biceps band costs ~โฌ60 in Austria (frame_0044.jpg).
Hook microscope (0-10s)
- Frames: 20 at 2 fps
- Word-level transcript (27 words):
[ 0.00s] I
[ 0.46s] performed
[ 0.78s] systematic
[ 1.52s] and
[ 1.92s] scientific
[ 2.46s] testing
[ 3.00s] of
[ 3.36s] the
[ 3.56s] Garmin
[ 3.96s] Circa
[ 4.44s] to
[ 4.94s] find
[ 5.24s] out
[ 5.62s] how
[ 5.92s] good
[ 6.10s] it
[ 6.18s] is
[ 6.42s] at
[ 6.56s] heart
[ 6.92s] rate
[ 7.08s] tracking
[ 7.36s] during
[ 7.64s] exercise
[ 8.34s] at
[ 8.92s] night
[ 9.36s] time
[ 9.60s] measurements
Hook pattern: credibility-first results tease (demo-first variant). It opens on a talking-head shot: Rob at his desk holds both CIRQA retail boxes up to the lens (0.0-4.4s) while the words land on "systematic and scientific testing". He skips any question or contrarian claim and goes straight from the promise of method ("I performed systematic and scientific testing") to the three deliverables viewers came for: exercise HR (7.1s), nighttime (8.9s), sleep stages (~10s). Energy comes from Rob's animated delivery and the neon bike/dumbbell set dressing. The first real cut (to side-by-side scatter-plot B-roll) lands at ~7s, exactly as "heart rate tracking" is spoken.
Editorial profile
- Shots: 52
- Cuts/min: 1.99
- Mean shot length: 30.09s
- Median shot length: 5.94s
- Talking-head ratio: n/a (opencv not installed)
Slow, lecture-paced science explainer (~2 cuts/min, 30s mean shot): long talking-head takes alternating with full-screen iPad data plots and annotated spreadsheets, sparse product B-roll on a cutting mat, no motion graphics โ the data visuals are the production value.
Quotable moments
- [06:57] "Definitely you cannot use it reliably, at least, while weightlifting on the wrist."
- [09:30] "On the biceps, the Garmin Circa is one of the better devices out there."
- [12:33] "Here's where I was really surprised, because when wearing it on my biceps, the performance really improved, and I cannot really explain this."
- [23:39] "I wouldn't wear it on my wrist full-time because it really cripples performance."
- [24:37] "I'm not disappointed with the performance of the Circa and I think it is a proper competitor to the Fitbit Air, but also the Whoop strap."
Entities mentioned
- People: rob-ter-horst (The Quantified Scientist, host), Alex (editor)
- Companies:
garmin,fitbit,google,apple,whoop,amazfit,oura,eight-sleep,polar,ultrahuman - Tools / products: garmin-cirqa,
polar-h10,zmax-eeg,fitbit-air,whoop-strap,amazfit-helios-strap, apple-watch,pixel-watch,oura-ring,eight-sleep-pod,garmin-forerunner-570,garmin-forerunner-70 - Places:
austria(pricing/availability context)
Concepts surfaced
- sensor-placement-effect: where a wearable sits (wrist vs biceps) can matter more than which device you buy; the same CIRQA scored HR 98 on the biceps and 93 on the wrist.
- reference-device-validation: judge a wearable by correlating it against a trusted reference (ECG chest strap for HR, EEG for sleep).
correlation-scoring: summarizing tracker accuracy as a Pearson correlation vs reference, averaged across exercises into a 0-100 score.silver-vs-gold-standard: a consumer EEG headband is "good enough" for comparative sleep-stage testing without a full polysomnography lab.device-tier-ranking: plotting average vs worst-stage sleep sensitivity and dividing the field into four tiers to make buy/skip calls.chance-vs-signal: explicitly entertaining "small sample size" as an alternative explanation before accepting a surprising result โ and committing to more data collection to resolve it.
Transcript
Source: captions.
[00:03] I performed systematic and scientific testing of the Garmin Circa to find out
[00:06] testing of the Garmin Circa to find out how good it is at heart rate tracking
[00:07] how good it is at heart rate tracking during exercise, at nighttime
[00:10] during exercise, at nighttime measurements, and at measuring your
[00:11] measurements, and at measuring your sleep stages. And I tested both on the
[00:14] sleep stages. And I tested both on the wrist and on the biceps, and I think
[00:17] wrist and on the biceps, and I think that distinction between where you wear
[00:19] that distinction between where you wear it is very important because it will
[00:21] it is very important because it will influence performance, and it will also
[00:23] influence performance, and it will also influence my recommendations to all of
[00:25] influence my recommendations to all of you. Now, for those of you who are new
[00:27] you. Now, for those of you who are new to the channel, my name is Rob, and I'm
[00:28] to the channel, my name is Rob, and I'm a post-doctoral scientist specializing
[00:30] a post-doctoral scientist specializing in biological data analysis. And that's
[00:32] in biological data analysis. And that's the exact focus of today, data and data
[00:36] the exact focus of today, data and data science and analyzing systematic tests
[00:39] science and analyzing systematic tests of the Garmin Circa. And as I said, I
[00:41] of the Garmin Circa. And as I said, I tested it both on the wrist and on the
[00:44] tested it both on the wrist and on the biceps, always with the official bands
[00:47] biceps, always with the official bands and everything set according to the
[00:48] and everything set according to the specifications,
[00:50] specifications, and I will always present them side by
[00:52] and I will always present them side by side as you see it here, always starting
[00:55] side as you see it here, always starting with the data on the wrist and then
[00:57] with the data on the wrist and then showing the biceps data. So, you can get
[00:59] showing the biceps data. So, you can get a good impression of the performance of
[01:02] a good impression of the performance of the Garmin Circa and if it's the right
[01:04] the Garmin Circa and if it's the right choice for you and where you want to
[01:06] choice for you and where you want to wear it. Now, before getting into this
[01:07] wear it. Now, before getting into this data, one quick side note, I actually
[01:09] data, one quick side note, I actually bought two colors and received one from
[01:11] bought two colors and received one from Garmin, and I think the blue color and
[01:14] Garmin, and I think the blue color and the black color really look like they
[01:16] the black color really look like they are on the box. However, the reddish
[01:18] are on the box. However, the reddish color really looks very different than
[01:20] color really looks very different than it does on the box as you can see right
[01:23] it does on the box as you can see right here. So, it's much more of a faded pink
[01:27] here. So, it's much more of a faded pink than this kind of dark red color that is
[01:29] than this kind of dark red color that is on the box. So, be aware, I am not a
[01:32] on the box. So, be aware, I am not a particular fan of this color. It almost
[01:34] particular fan of this color. It almost looks like it's been in the sun too
[01:36] looks like it's been in the sun too long, but I just wanted to mention that.
[01:38] long, but I just wanted to mention that. Otherwise, I do like the design of the
[01:41] Otherwise, I do like the design of the Circa, and especially when worn on the
[01:43] Circa, and especially when worn on the biceps, it doesn't look so big. But as
[01:46] biceps, it doesn't look so big. But as you can see, it is a lot bigger than the
[01:48] you can see, it is a lot bigger than the Fitbit Air, for instance. But today,
[01:50] Fitbit Air, for instance. But today, we're focusing on the Garmin Circa, and
[01:52] we're focusing on the Garmin Circa, and let's start with the heart rate tracking
[01:54] let's start with the heart rate tracking during exercise. Now, the way I test
[01:56] during exercise. Now, the way I test devices is by comparing them to a
[01:58] devices is by comparing them to a reference device. In this case, the
[02:00] reference device. In this case, the Polar H10 ECG chest strap, which can
[02:03] Polar H10 ECG chest strap, which can measure my heart rate very reliably. And
[02:05] measure my heart rate very reliably. And that's always along the horizontal axis
[02:08] that's always along the horizontal axis in these kinds of plots. Then along the
[02:10] in these kinds of plots. Then along the vertical axis, we have the results
[02:12] vertical axis, we have the results according to the Circa with the
[02:14] according to the Circa with the wrist-based testing on the left and the
[02:16] wrist-based testing on the left and the biceps-based testing on the right. And
[02:18] biceps-based testing on the right. And this is for indoor cycling or spinning,
[02:21] this is for indoor cycling or spinning, one of the easier exercises for a device
[02:23] one of the easier exercises for a device to track. And in both situations, both
[02:27] to track. And in both situations, both on the wrist and the biceps, it's doing
[02:29] on the wrist and the biceps, it's doing really well. So, on the wrist, it gets a
[02:31] really well. So, on the wrist, it gets a correlation of 0.99, and the maximum
[02:34] correlation of 0.99, and the maximum correlation is one, so that's really
[02:35] correlation is one, so that's really good. And on the biceps, it's even
[02:38] good. And on the biceps, it's even better at a rounded correlation of 1.00.
[02:41] better at a rounded correlation of 1.00. So, almost perfect with just a few
[02:43] So, almost perfect with just a few moments of deviation. And if we take a
[02:45] moments of deviation. And if we take a look at some example spinning sessions
[02:47] look at some example spinning sessions with the Circa in red and the Polar H10
[02:50] with the Circa in red and the Polar H10 in blue-green, we generally see good
[02:52] in blue-green, we generally see good agreement for the wrist, a little bit of
[02:54] agreement for the wrist, a little bit of deviation here in the beginning. And
[02:56] deviation here in the beginning. And another wrist example, some tiny
[02:58] another wrist example, some tiny deviations. Otherwise, quite good, I
[03:01] deviations. Otherwise, quite good, I would say. This is already good enough.
[03:03] would say. This is already good enough. And then on the biceps, it's even
[03:05] And then on the biceps, it's even better, as you can see right here.
[03:06] better, as you can see right here. Basically, no deviation. Also, this
[03:09] Basically, no deviation. Also, this example, almost perfect. And this was
[03:12] example, almost perfect. And this was the only example with a bit of deviation
[03:14] the only example with a bit of deviation right here and right here. But it's so
[03:16] right here and right here. But it's so minimal that I would say this is
[03:18] minimal that I would say this is basically perfect performance. So,
[03:20] basically perfect performance. So, definitely good on the wrist, but even
[03:23] definitely good on the wrist, but even better on the biceps.
[03:25] better on the biceps. But what about running? This can be
[03:28] But what about running? This can be quite a bit harder, and that's exactly
[03:30] quite a bit harder, and that's exactly what we see here. So, again, the wrist
[03:32] what we see here. So, again, the wrist on the left and the biceps on the right.
[03:35] on the left and the biceps on the right. And we can see that on the right, almost
[03:37] And we can see that on the right, almost all points are on or close to the blue
[03:39] all points are on or close to the blue line. But on the left right here,
[03:41] line. But on the left right here, there's quite a bit more deviation. It's
[03:44] there's quite a bit more deviation. It's not horrible, but the correlation
[03:46] not horrible, but the correlation overall is quite a bit lower now at
[03:48] overall is quite a bit lower now at 0.89.
[03:49] 0.89. Whereas for on the biceps, it's again
[03:51] Whereas for on the biceps, it's again super close to one at 0.98.
[03:55] super close to one at 0.98. So, there it's definitely a lot better
[03:58] So, there it's definitely a lot better when worn on the biceps. And for this
[04:00] when worn on the biceps. And for this exercise, at least on my testing, I can
[04:03] exercise, at least on my testing, I can really recommend getting a biceps band.
[04:05] really recommend getting a biceps band. And we can see that when we take a look
[04:06] And we can see that when we take a look at the individual runs. So, here we have
[04:08] at the individual runs. So, here we have the results for the wrist within red,
[04:11] the results for the wrist within red, the Garmin Circa, and blue green, the
[04:12] the Garmin Circa, and blue green, the reference. And we can definitely see a
[04:15] reference. And we can definitely see a bunch of deviation. This wrist exercise
[04:18] bunch of deviation. This wrist exercise looked a bit better, a bit of deviation,
[04:20] looked a bit better, a bit of deviation, but nothing terrible. But then for
[04:22] but nothing terrible. But then for instance, this run was a lot worse with
[04:24] instance, this run was a lot worse with a lot of spikes in heart rate that
[04:26] a lot of spikes in heart rate that weren't really there. And also here in
[04:27] weren't really there. And also here in the beginning, a bunch of spikes. So,
[04:30] the beginning, a bunch of spikes. So, I'm not sure what was going on here, but
[04:32] I'm not sure what was going on here, but here it really struggled. But if we then
[04:34] here it really struggled. But if we then move to the biceps, this is much better.
[04:37] move to the biceps, this is much better. Here it tracked all my intervals
[04:39] Here it tracked all my intervals correctly, so all the dips in my heart
[04:41] correctly, so all the dips in my heart rate. Only in the beginning did it have
[04:43] rate. Only in the beginning did it have to calibrate a bit.
[04:44] to calibrate a bit. Also this run, almost perfect with a bit
[04:47] Also this run, almost perfect with a bit of deviation. And also right here,
[04:49] of deviation. And also right here, nothing to complain about. So, here it
[04:51] nothing to complain about. So, here it seems it really pays off to wear it on
[04:54] seems it really pays off to wear it on your biceps instead of your wrist for
[04:56] your biceps instead of your wrist for running, at least on me, on my body.
[04:59] running, at least on me, on my body. Now, I always wore it on my left wrist
[05:01] Now, I always wore it on my left wrist as well, but I didn't wear the
[05:03] as well, but I didn't wear the wrist-worn and the biceps-worn
[05:05] wrist-worn and the biceps-worn simultaneously, so I did two periods of
[05:07] simultaneously, so I did two periods of testing. But what about biking? Well,
[05:10] testing. But what about biking? Well, again here we see a difference between
[05:12] again here we see a difference between wrist-worn and biceps-worn,
[05:15] wrist-worn and biceps-worn, but the difference is a bit smaller. The
[05:17] but the difference is a bit smaller. The correlation for biking is 0.92. This is
[05:20] correlation for biking is 0.92. This is still quite good, I would say. There are
[05:22] still quite good, I would say. There are some moments where it detects it to low
[05:24] some moments where it detects it to low heart rate, and also some moments where
[05:26] heart rate, and also some moments where it detects it to high heart rate, but
[05:29] it detects it to high heart rate, but it's not that bad, honestly. And on the
[05:31] it's not that bad, honestly. And on the biceps, this is even better. Most points
[05:34] biceps, this is even better. Most points are on or close to the blue line. There
[05:36] are on or close to the blue line. There were just a few moments where it
[05:38] were just a few moments where it detected it to low heart rate, but the
[05:40] detected it to low heart rate, but the correlation is a lot higher now at 0.96.
[05:44] correlation is a lot higher now at 0.96. So, this looks really good. And if we
[05:45] So, this looks really good. And if we take a look at some examples, so here we
[05:47] take a look at some examples, so here we have the wrist-worn example. This
[05:49] have the wrist-worn example. This already looks quite good for this
[05:50] already looks quite good for this example session. Also here, it's
[05:52] example session. Also here, it's relatively minor, mostly some delays in
[05:55] relatively minor, mostly some delays in picking up on changes in my heart rate.
[05:58] picking up on changes in my heart rate. And here we had some weird peaks again,
[06:00] And here we had some weird peaks again, but otherwise this is already not that
[06:02] but otherwise this is already not that bad, honestly. And compared to the
[06:04] bad, honestly. And compared to the competition, quite good. But then if we
[06:06] competition, quite good. But then if we look at the biceps result, this is much
[06:08] look at the biceps result, this is much better. So, much closer to reality. Here
[06:11] better. So, much closer to reality. Here a small deviation, but really very
[06:14] a small deviation, but really very minor. And this would be really good in
[06:16] minor. And this would be really good in my opinion. So, also for biking, it does
[06:20] my opinion. So, also for biking, it does pay off, at least on my body, to wear it
[06:22] pay off, at least on my body, to wear it on your biceps compared to the wrist.
[06:24] on your biceps compared to the wrist. Now, at night, that might be a bit
[06:26] Now, at night, that might be a bit different that you'll see in a second.
[06:28] different that you'll see in a second. But I want to close off by looking at
[06:30] But I want to close off by looking at strength training. And here it usually
[06:32] strength training. And here it usually pays off a lot to wear it on your biceps
[06:34] pays off a lot to wear it on your biceps versus the wrist, cuz there's so much
[06:37] versus the wrist, cuz there's so much tension on your wrist when you're
[06:38] tension on your wrist when you're weightlifting.
[06:40] weightlifting. And here, surprisingly, it also wasn't
[06:43] And here, surprisingly, it also wasn't quite as good as I'd hoped on the
[06:46] quite as good as I'd hoped on the biceps, but it is definitely a lot
[06:48] biceps, but it is definitely a lot better. So, on the biceps, we got a
[06:50] better. So, on the biceps, we got a correlation of 0.91 for strength
[06:52] correlation of 0.91 for strength training, whereas on the wrist, the
[06:55] training, whereas on the wrist, the correlation is 0.73. So, really low. So,
[06:58] correlation is 0.73. So, really low. So, definitely you cannot use it reliably,
[07:01] definitely you cannot use it reliably, at least, while weightlifting on the
[07:03] at least, while weightlifting on the wrist. On the biceps, it's still a lot
[07:05] wrist. On the biceps, it's still a lot better. In the higher heart rate range,
[07:07] better. In the higher heart rate range, we have too low heart rate sometimes,
[07:10] we have too low heart rate sometimes, but as you'll see, it's not the worst.
[07:12] but as you'll see, it's not the worst. So, here we have some wrist-based
[07:14] So, here we have some wrist-based example. You can see that many of the
[07:16] example. You can see that many of the peaks were not tracked and some weird
[07:18] peaks were not tracked and some weird heart rates were tracked. Also here on
[07:20] heart rates were tracked. Also here on the wrist, many of the peaks in my heart
[07:23] the wrist, many of the peaks in my heart rate were missed.
[07:25] rate were missed. But on the biceps, it's also far from
[07:27] But on the biceps, it's also far from perfect. This weightlifting session,
[07:29] perfect. This weightlifting session, some of the peaks were missed, so
[07:30] some of the peaks were missed, so definitely not great. This was a lot
[07:32] definitely not great. This was a lot better. So, here I was bench pressing,
[07:35] better. So, here I was bench pressing, and there it did actually quite okay.
[07:37] and there it did actually quite okay. Most of the peaks were generally
[07:39] Most of the peaks were generally detected. And here during dips, I
[07:41] detected. And here during dips, I believe, it was also still quite good,
[07:43] believe, it was also still quite good, and this is where many devices struggle.
[07:46] and this is where many devices struggle. So, overall, not the worst, but also not
[07:48] So, overall, not the worst, but also not the best, but I would definitely again
[07:50] the best, but I would definitely again recommend wearing it on the biceps. But,
[07:52] recommend wearing it on the biceps. But, we can again compare this performance to
[07:54] we can again compare this performance to that of the competition that's displayed
[07:56] that of the competition that's displayed right here for the wrist-based wearing
[08:00] right here for the wrist-based wearing with the four exercises we looked at
[08:02] with the four exercises we looked at before. So, spinning, biking, running,
[08:05] before. So, spinning, biking, running, and weightlifting, where we used that
[08:07] and weightlifting, where we used that correlation value here along the
[08:09] correlation value here along the vertical axis, so the higher the better.
[08:11] vertical axis, so the higher the better. And the Garmin Circa is indicated with a
[08:14] And the Garmin Circa is indicated with a red line and a red dot, and it's doing
[08:16] red line and a red dot, and it's doing really well for spinning. So, there I'm
[08:19] really well for spinning. So, there I'm happy, and it's doing better than 63% of
[08:21] happy, and it's doing better than 63% of devices I've tested in the past, but
[08:23] devices I've tested in the past, but it's so high up that it's basically good
[08:25] it's so high up that it's basically good enough.
[08:26] enough. Then, we have biking. There, I would say
[08:29] Then, we have biking. There, I would say it's starting to struggle. It's doing
[08:30] it's starting to struggle. It's doing better than just over 50% of devices, so
[08:33] better than just over 50% of devices, so still quite okay, but here there are
[08:35] still quite okay, but here there are definitely devices that are doing
[08:37] definitely devices that are doing significantly better.
[08:39] significantly better. And for running right here, we can see
[08:41] And for running right here, we can see it's really a bit of an issue, at least
[08:43] it's really a bit of an issue, at least on my body. The correlation is 0.89, so
[08:46] on my body. The correlation is 0.89, so quite low, and it's doing better than
[08:48] quite low, and it's doing better than only 27% of devices, so 73% of devices
[08:53] only 27% of devices, so 73% of devices were doing better than the Garmin Circa
[08:55] were doing better than the Garmin Circa on the wrist. And also for
[08:57] on the wrist. And also for weightlifting, it's really not that
[08:58] weightlifting, it's really not that good. However, as we saw, that changes
[09:01] good. However, as we saw, that changes when you wear it on the biceps. So, for
[09:04] when you wear it on the biceps. So, for spinning, a correlation of 1.00, doing
[09:07] spinning, a correlation of 1.00, doing better than 77% of devices.
[09:10] better than 77% of devices. On the bike, a correlation of 0.96,
[09:12] On the bike, a correlation of 0.96, doing better than three-quarters of
[09:15] doing better than three-quarters of devices.
[09:16] devices. Then, for running, also a high
[09:18] Then, for running, also a high correlation at 0.98, doing better than
[09:20] correlation at 0.98, doing better than 63% of devices.
[09:23] 63% of devices. And for weightlifting, still doing
[09:25] And for weightlifting, still doing better than close to 70% of devices with
[09:28] better than close to 70% of devices with a correlation of 0.91.
[09:31] a correlation of 0.91. So, on the biceps, the Garmin Circa is
[09:33] So, on the biceps, the Garmin Circa is one of the better devices out there, and
[09:35] one of the better devices out there, and then I can definitely recommend it for
[09:37] then I can definitely recommend it for those that want to use it during
[09:38] those that want to use it during exercise. And we usually give this
[09:40] exercise. And we usually give this course. Now, I will give a separate
[09:43] course. Now, I will give a separate score for the biceps and the wrist. And
[09:46] score for the biceps and the wrist. And this is calculated as the average
[09:48] this is calculated as the average correlation over the three cardio
[09:50] correlation over the three cardio exercises. So, the heart rate score for
[09:53] exercises. So, the heart rate score for the Garmin Circa worn on the biceps is
[09:55] the Garmin Circa worn on the biceps is 98, which is really good.
[09:59] 98, which is really good. However, on the wrist, it's a bit lower
[10:00] However, on the wrist, it's a bit lower at 93. Still good, I would say, but not
[10:03] at 93. Still good, I would say, but not great, which is why the Garmin Circa on
[10:06] great, which is why the Garmin Circa on the biceps gets a rating of great,
[10:08] the biceps gets a rating of great, whereas on the wrist, it just gets a
[10:10] whereas on the wrist, it just gets a rating of good.
[10:12] rating of good. And that's mostly influenced by those
[10:14] And that's mostly influenced by those running results and also somewhat by
[10:17] running results and also somewhat by those biking results. It's still not
[10:19] those biking results. It's still not terrible, but it could be better, which
[10:21] terrible, but it could be better, which is why it's only good. So, again, I
[10:23] is why it's only good. So, again, I really recommend wearing it on the
[10:25] really recommend wearing it on the biceps. But, what about sleep stage
[10:28] biceps. But, what about sleep stage tracking? Can it track your sleep
[10:30] tracking? Can it track your sleep reliably at night? And this was
[10:32] reliably at night? And this was surprisingly good, but I'll get to that
[10:34] surprisingly good, but I'll get to that in a second. First, I quickly want to
[10:37] in a second. First, I quickly want to ask for your support because running
[10:38] ask for your support because running this channel next to my full-time job as
[10:40] this channel next to my full-time job as a scientist is neither easy or cheap. I
[10:43] a scientist is neither easy or cheap. I have to pay my editor, Alex, for
[10:45] have to pay my editor, Alex, for instance. I have a bunch of camera gear.
[10:47] instance. I have a bunch of camera gear. And of course, it just costs a lot of
[10:49] And of course, it just costs a lot of effort to keep this going. Now, if you
[10:51] effort to keep this going. Now, if you want to support there's multiple ways of
[10:52] want to support there's multiple ways of doing that. The easiest way is by using
[10:54] doing that. The easiest way is by using my affiliate links down below. If you do
[10:56] my affiliate links down below. If you do end up getting a Circa or maybe you want
[10:59] end up getting a Circa or maybe you want a Whoop strap, an Amazfit Helios strap,
[11:01] a Whoop strap, an Amazfit Helios strap, a Fitbit there, another device, or
[11:03] a Fitbit there, another device, or anything at all on Amazon for that
[11:05] anything at all on Amazon for that matter. Also have a general link. If you
[11:07] matter. Also have a general link. If you use that before making any Amazon
[11:08] use that before making any Amazon purchase, you support the channel each
[11:11] purchase, you support the channel each time you make a purchase. And if there's
[11:13] time you make a purchase. And if there's a discount, these affiliate links give
[11:14] a discount, these affiliate links give you the best discount possible. Thanks
[11:17] you the best discount possible. Thanks so much for considering. Also, don't
[11:18] so much for considering. Also, don't forget to like this video and subscribe
[11:21] forget to like this video and subscribe to the channel.
[11:22] to the channel. But, let's get back to the testing. Now,
[11:24] But, let's get back to the testing. Now, the way I test the sleep stages is by
[11:27] the way I test the sleep stages is by comparing it against the ZMax EEG
[11:29] comparing it against the ZMax EEG device, which can actually measure my
[11:31] device, which can actually measure my brain waves and was specifically
[11:33] brain waves and was specifically designed for sleep studies. Now, this is
[11:35] designed for sleep studies. Now, this is sort of a silver standard, not a gold
[11:37] sort of a silver standard, not a gold standard, but good enough to give an
[11:38] standard, but good enough to give an impression of the sleep stage tracking
[11:40] impression of the sleep stage tracking performance.
[11:41] performance. So, on top in this overview, we have the
[11:43] So, on top in this overview, we have the reference device, so deep sleep, light
[11:45] reference device, so deep sleep, light sleep, and REM sleep. And then on the
[11:47] sleep, and REM sleep. And then on the left here, we have the Garmin Circa, in
[11:50] left here, we have the Garmin Circa, in this case, the wrist-based tracking.
[11:53] this case, the wrist-based tracking. Now, deep sleep agreement is actually
[11:54] Now, deep sleep agreement is actually quite good at 81%.
[11:57] quite good at 81%. So, 81% of what the reference said was
[12:00] So, 81% of what the reference said was deep sleep was also deep sleep according
[12:02] deep sleep was also deep sleep according to the Circa one on the wrist. The light
[12:05] to the Circa one on the wrist. The light sleep tracking here is okay, I would
[12:07] sleep tracking here is okay, I would say, at 67%,
[12:09] say, at 67%, but quite a bit of light sleep according
[12:11] but quite a bit of light sleep according to the reference was instead read as
[12:12] to the reference was instead read as deep sleep, REM sleep, and awake time.
[12:16] deep sleep, REM sleep, and awake time. And finally, REM sleep agreement is
[12:18] And finally, REM sleep agreement is where the Circa, on me at least, really
[12:20] where the Circa, on me at least, really struggled. Only about 45% of what the
[12:23] struggled. Only about 45% of what the reference said was REM sleep was also
[12:25] reference said was REM sleep was also detected as REM sleep by the Circa.
[12:28] detected as REM sleep by the Circa. Instead, quite a bit over 50% was
[12:31] Instead, quite a bit over 50% was predicted as being light sleep. But,
[12:33] predicted as being light sleep. But, here's where I was really surprised,
[12:35] here's where I was really surprised, because when wearing it on my biceps,
[12:38] because when wearing it on my biceps, the performance really improved, and I
[12:40] the performance really improved, and I cannot really explain this. So, right
[12:43] cannot really explain this. So, right here, we see the deep sleep agreement is
[12:45] here, we see the deep sleep agreement is now 91%.
[12:47] now 91%. Light sleep agreement is actually very
[12:49] Light sleep agreement is actually very similar at about 69%,
[12:51] similar at about 69%, but now REM sleep agreement is quite a
[12:53] but now REM sleep agreement is quite a bit better at 58%. So, it increased
[12:56] bit better at 58%. So, it increased quite a bit,
[12:57] quite a bit, and I cannot fully explain it. I have
[12:59] and I cannot fully explain it. I have some theories, and I'll get to those in
[13:01] some theories, and I'll get to those in a second, but let's first take a look at
[13:03] a second, but let's first take a look at some example nights. First, for on the
[13:05] some example nights. First, for on the wrist right here. So, on top, we have
[13:07] wrist right here. So, on top, we have the reference, on the bottom, the Garmin
[13:09] the reference, on the bottom, the Garmin Circa. And I marked the deep sleep as
[13:11] Circa. And I marked the deep sleep as detected by the reference device in sort
[13:14] detected by the reference device in sort of purple, and we can see that much of
[13:16] of purple, and we can see that much of the deep sleep detected, almost all of
[13:17] the deep sleep detected, almost all of it by the reference, is also detected by
[13:19] it by the reference, is also detected by the Circa, but some extra was detected.
[13:22] the Circa, but some extra was detected. And we see the same for this night,
[13:23] And we see the same for this night, again, on the wrist. Most of the deep
[13:25] again, on the wrist. Most of the deep sleep was correctly detected. So, deep
[13:27] sleep was correctly detected. So, deep sleep doesn't appear to be the issue.
[13:29] sleep doesn't appear to be the issue. Though, as you can see right here, for
[13:31] Though, as you can see right here, for instance, on the biceps, some extra deep
[13:33] instance, on the biceps, some extra deep sleep is sometimes detected. And the
[13:35] sleep is sometimes detected. And the same here. Most of the deep sleep is
[13:37] same here. Most of the deep sleep is correctly detected, just a bunch of
[13:38] correctly detected, just a bunch of extra is there as well. And this is a
[13:40] extra is there as well. And this is a general pattern, but where it mostly
[13:42] general pattern, but where it mostly struggles is REM sleep, and it seems to
[13:44] struggles is REM sleep, and it seems to detect less REM sleep on me in general.
[13:47] detect less REM sleep on me in general. So, here you can actually see, according
[13:49] So, here you can actually see, according to the reference on top, I had 1 2 3 4 5
[13:52] to the reference on top, I had 1 2 3 4 5 sleep cycles, all of them ending in REM
[13:54] sleep cycles, all of them ending in REM sleep, but only some of these endings of
[13:57] sleep, but only some of these endings of my sleep cycle were detected by the
[13:59] my sleep cycle were detected by the Garmin Circa, only three out of five in
[14:02] Garmin Circa, only three out of five in this case.
[14:04] this case. Also, for this night right here, you can
[14:05] Also, for this night right here, you can see that much of the REM sleep is
[14:07] see that much of the REM sleep is detected, but not all of it, and also
[14:09] detected, but not all of it, and also some of it is missed. And the same is
[14:11] some of it is missed. And the same is true here on the biceps, where here a
[14:13] true here on the biceps, where here a lot of it was detected as awake time.
[14:15] lot of it was detected as awake time. This part was missed, but some of it was
[14:17] This part was missed, but some of it was correctly detected. And in general, for
[14:20] correctly detected. And in general, for the biceps, it seemed that a little bit
[14:22] the biceps, it seemed that a little bit more REM sleep was correctly detected
[14:24] more REM sleep was correctly detected as, for instance, for this night right
[14:25] as, for instance, for this night right here, where basically all of the
[14:27] here, where basically all of the segments, at least, are correct, but the
[14:28] segments, at least, are correct, but the duration is a bit different. And you can
[14:30] duration is a bit different. And you can see the same here, that a little bit
[14:32] see the same here, that a little bit more REM sleep was detected here, but
[14:34] more REM sleep was detected here, but the exact location of the segments
[14:36] the exact location of the segments wasn't the exact same. This is a little
[14:38] wasn't the exact same. This is a little bit more in line with the reference.
[14:40] bit more in line with the reference. Now, we can actually compare this
[14:42] Now, we can actually compare this performance of both devices, also that
[14:44] performance of both devices, also that of the competition out there, and that's
[14:46] of the competition out there, and that's displayed in this overview right here,
[14:48] displayed in this overview right here, where along the horizontal axis, we have
[14:50] where along the horizontal axis, we have the average sensitivity over those three
[14:53] the average sensitivity over those three sleep stages, and along the vertical
[14:55] sleep stages, and along the vertical axis, we have the worst out of those
[14:57] axis, we have the worst out of those three sleep stages. It would be REM
[14:59] three sleep stages. It would be REM sleep in this case. And we can see the
[15:01] sleep in this case. And we can see the Garmin Circa on the wrist and on the
[15:03] Garmin Circa on the wrist and on the biceps on really two different
[15:04] biceps on really two different positions. So, here we have the Garmin
[15:06] positions. So, here we have the Garmin Circa on the wrist,
[15:08] Circa on the wrist, and right here, we have the Garmin Circa
[15:11] and right here, we have the Garmin Circa on the biceps.
[15:12] on the biceps. >> [music]
[15:12] >> [music] >> And the better devices are towards the
[15:14] >> And the better devices are towards the top right. And the Garmin Circa now is
[15:17] top right. And the Garmin Circa now is in sort of the second tier of device, so
[15:19] in sort of the second tier of device, so getting quite good when worn on the
[15:21] getting quite good when worn on the biceps, but on the wrist, it's quite a
[15:24] biceps, but on the wrist, it's quite a bit lower, more in the third tier of
[15:26] bit lower, more in the third tier of devices. And interestingly, I don't
[15:28] devices. And interestingly, I don't think I ever published a video, but I
[15:30] think I ever published a video, but I did some testing of the Garmin
[15:31] did some testing of the Garmin Forerunner 570 on my biceps, that also
[15:35] Forerunner 570 on my biceps, that also did a little bit better. The overall,
[15:37] did a little bit better. The overall, the Forerunner 70, which I recently
[15:39] the Forerunner 70, which I recently tested, was already a little bit
[15:40] tested, was already a little bit improved compared to some other testing
[15:42] improved compared to some other testing that I did. So, what does this mean? Why
[15:44] that I did. So, what does this mean? Why do I get better sleep stage tracking
[15:45] do I get better sleep stage tracking results on my biceps than on my wrist?
[15:48] results on my biceps than on my wrist? Well, there's a couple of things I can
[15:49] Well, there's a couple of things I can think of. First of all, maybe there's
[15:51] think of. First of all, maybe there's just less artifacts when you wear it on
[15:53] just less artifacts when you wear it on your biceps. And it could be because
[15:55] your biceps. And it could be because there is fewer degrees of freedom, so
[15:57] there is fewer degrees of freedom, so less noise in the signal. There's a
[15:59] less noise in the signal. There's a clearer heart rate signal. Everything is
[16:01] clearer heart rate signal. Everything is just measured much easier on the biceps
[16:04] just measured much easier on the biceps with less noise, which could make it
[16:06] with less noise, which could make it easier for the algorithms to get
[16:08] easier for the algorithms to get reliable sleep stage tracking. Whereas
[16:10] reliable sleep stage tracking. Whereas on the wrist, there's just an extra
[16:12] on the wrist, there's just an extra degree of freedom of movement at night,
[16:14] degree of freedom of movement at night, which could interfere with the signals.
[16:16] which could interfere with the signals. So, that's one explanation. Maybe the
[16:17] So, that's one explanation. Maybe the input data is better.
[16:19] input data is better. The second explanation could be that
[16:21] The second explanation could be that this is by chance. This is just because
[16:23] this is by chance. This is just because I did too little testing, and overall,
[16:25] I did too little testing, and overall, they would end up in the middle
[16:26] they would end up in the middle somewhere. That could also be true. And
[16:28] somewhere. That could also be true. And I'm not really sure what the explanation
[16:30] I'm not really sure what the explanation is. Is it actually better on the biceps,
[16:32] is. Is it actually better on the biceps, or is it by chance? Well, I will
[16:35] or is it by chance? Well, I will actually keep wearing the Garmin Circa
[16:36] actually keep wearing the Garmin Circa on my biceps to see if this sort of
[16:39] on my biceps to see if this sort of pattern holds, or if it actually
[16:41] pattern holds, or if it actually degrades a bit over time and ends up
[16:44] degrades a bit over time and ends up maybe in the middle here somewhere. If
[16:46] maybe in the middle here somewhere. If the first explanation is true, that
[16:48] the first explanation is true, that would also mean that if you get a good
[16:50] would also mean that if you get a good signal on the wrist, that potentially
[16:52] signal on the wrist, that potentially the sleep stage tracking also gets
[16:53] the sleep stage tracking also gets better. As you will see, for instance,
[16:55] better. As you will see, for instance, in my Garmin Forerunner 170 review,
[16:57] in my Garmin Forerunner 170 review, where I only had a few nights of data,
[16:59] where I only had a few nights of data, that was also quite a bit better. So,
[17:01] that was also quite a bit better. So, potentially, if the fit is really good
[17:02] potentially, if the fit is really good and the input signal is good, it could
[17:04] and the input signal is good, it could be that the Garmin Circa, or whatever
[17:07] be that the Garmin Circa, or whatever device you're wearing from Garmin, is
[17:08] device you're wearing from Garmin, is actually quite decent at sleep stage
[17:10] actually quite decent at sleep stage tracking. In general, it is promising to
[17:12] tracking. In general, it is promising to see that most of the devices I tested
[17:14] see that most of the devices I tested relatively recently from Garmin do end
[17:17] relatively recently from Garmin do end up sort of more in this second, high
[17:19] up sort of more in this second, high third tier of devices instead of all the
[17:21] third tier of devices instead of all the way down here. So, it does seem that
[17:23] way down here. So, it does seem that potentially there has been some
[17:25] potentially there has been some improvement with Garmin. Now, just to
[17:27] improvement with Garmin. Now, just to clarify, what do I mean when I talk
[17:28] clarify, what do I mean when I talk about tiers of testing? Well, I usually
[17:30] about tiers of testing? Well, I usually divide this graph into four segments
[17:32] divide this graph into four segments where we have first tier right here,
[17:35] where we have first tier right here, which are the best devices. Then we
[17:37] which are the best devices. Then we roughly have second tier right here. And
[17:41] roughly have second tier right here. And then, depending if it's still worth to
[17:42] then, depending if it's still worth to split it, you could say that there's
[17:45] split it, you could say that there's third tier here and
[17:48] third tier here and fourth tier here. But, I would already
[17:49] fourth tier here. But, I would already say that third tier and fourth tier
[17:51] say that third tier and fourth tier probably aren't worth much in terms of
[17:53] probably aren't worth much in terms of sleep stage tracking. If you are
[17:56] sleep stage tracking. If you are interested in your sleep stages at the
[17:58] interested in your sleep stages at the moment, I would recommend going for
[18:00] moment, I would recommend going for first tier or potentially second tier.
[18:02] first tier or potentially second tier. So, first tier in my testing include the
[18:05] So, first tier in my testing include the Apple Watch, the Pixel Watch, different
[18:08] Apple Watch, the Pixel Watch, different Fitbit devices. So, Fitbit and Pixel are
[18:11] Fitbit devices. So, Fitbit and Pixel are owned both by Google, so basically the
[18:12] owned both by Google, so basically the same algorithm. Then we have the Whoop
[18:15] same algorithm. Then we have the Whoop strap. My Oura Ring 4 testing, though
[18:17] strap. My Oura Ring 4 testing, though the Oura Ring 5 actually ended up in
[18:19] the Oura Ring 5 actually ended up in second tier. And then, of course, we
[18:21] second tier. And then, of course, we have the Eight Sleep Pod, my favorite
[18:23] have the Eight Sleep Pod, my favorite sleep improvement device. Now, I'll keep
[18:24] sleep improvement device. Now, I'll keep this short. It's not a wearable. It's a
[18:26] this short. It's not a wearable. It's a device that goes around your mattress
[18:27] device that goes around your mattress and it can also include a blanket that
[18:29] and it can also include a blanket that can actively cool and heat each side of
[18:32] can actively cool and heat each side of the bed for you and your partner
[18:33] the bed for you and your partner independently. For me, in summer, this
[18:35] independently. For me, in summer, this has been a game changer to improve my
[18:37] has been a game changer to improve my sleep. But, both in the shorter and
[18:39] sleep. But, both in the shorter and longer term, it's quite expensive. So,
[18:40] longer term, it's quite expensive. So, only get it if you can really afford it.
[18:43] only get it if you can really afford it. If you just want sleep stage tracking, I
[18:45] If you just want sleep stage tracking, I would definitely recommend going cheaper
[18:47] would definitely recommend going cheaper if you don't want that cooling
[18:48] if you don't want that cooling functionality. And you can get, for
[18:50] functionality. And you can get, for instance, a Fitbit Air for 99 bucks,
[18:52] instance, a Fitbit Air for 99 bucks, which already has really good sleep
[18:54] which already has really good sleep stage tracking. And now, potentially
[18:56] stage tracking. And now, potentially also the Garmin Circa on the biceps is
[18:58] also the Garmin Circa on the biceps is already quite good. And then, the Eight
[19:01] already quite good. And then, the Eight Sleep Pod is not worth it because it's
[19:02] Sleep Pod is not worth it because it's just so expensive. If you still want to
[19:04] just so expensive. If you still want to try it out to see if you like it and
[19:06] try it out to see if you like it and want to get the best discount possible,
[19:08] want to get the best discount possible, I do have an affiliate link to Eight
[19:09] I do have an affiliate link to Eight Sleep up here or down here.
[19:11] Sleep up here or down here. But, getting back to the testing, this
[19:12] But, getting back to the testing, this is looking promising and again,
[19:14] is looking promising and again, potentially a reason to wear your Garmin
[19:17] potentially a reason to wear your Garmin Circa on the biceps because it could
[19:19] Circa on the biceps because it could potentially give a more clean input
[19:21] potentially give a more clean input signal. So, let's actually score this
[19:24] signal. So, let's actually score this sleep stage tracking again on the biceps
[19:27] sleep stage tracking again on the biceps and the wrist separately. Then, the
[19:29] and the wrist separately. Then, the sleep score for the Circa on the biceps
[19:31] sleep score for the Circa on the biceps is 73 and on the wrist, 64, which gives
[19:36] is 73 and on the wrist, 64, which gives the Garmin Circa on the biceps a rating
[19:38] the Garmin Circa on the biceps a rating of good sleep stage tracking and on the
[19:40] of good sleep stage tracking and on the wrist, only okay. Still not the worst,
[19:43] wrist, only okay. Still not the worst, but definitely third tier.
[19:45] but definitely third tier. Now, one other thing that you can track
[19:47] Now, one other thing that you can track at night is your heart rate and heart
[19:49] at night is your heart rate and heart rate variability. And if you just care
[19:50] rate variability. And if you just care about that, there the Garmin Circa on
[19:52] about that, there the Garmin Circa on the wrist appears to be quite okay. So,
[19:54] the wrist appears to be quite okay. So, here we have the wrist-based results for
[19:56] here we have the wrist-based results for heart rate according to the reference
[19:58] heart rate according to the reference along the horizontal axis and the Circa
[20:00] along the horizontal axis and the Circa on the wrist along the vertical axis. We
[20:03] on the wrist along the vertical axis. We can indeed see that most points are on
[20:05] can indeed see that most points are on or close to the black line and we're
[20:06] or close to the black line and we're looking in a really narrow range. So,
[20:08] looking in a really narrow range. So, from 39 to let's say 55 bpm, it's just
[20:12] from 39 to let's say 55 bpm, it's just doing really well. And on the biceps,
[20:14] doing really well. And on the biceps, it's basically the same. The points are
[20:15] it's basically the same. The points are very close to the black line. So, both
[20:18] very close to the black line. So, both [music] would definitely be good enough
[20:20] [music] would definitely be good enough for me. We can look at some example
[20:21] for me. We can look at some example nights right here for the wrist, for
[20:23] nights right here for the wrist, for instance. So, we have the reference in
[20:25] instance. So, we have the reference in red and the Garmin Circa in blue-green
[20:27] red and the Garmin Circa in blue-green and they generally overlap very well in
[20:29] and they generally overlap very well in this narrow range with some minor
[20:30] this narrow range with some minor deviations. Also right here, the general
[20:33] deviations. Also right here, the general patterns agree very well also on the
[20:34] patterns agree very well also on the biceps. So, there there's not a big
[20:37] biceps. So, there there's not a big difference between wearing it on your
[20:38] difference between wearing it on your wrist or on the biceps and both are
[20:40] wrist or on the biceps and both are doing a good job. But, what about your
[20:42] doing a good job. But, what about your HRV or heart rate variability? Well,
[20:45] HRV or heart rate variability? Well, this is also generally measured quite
[20:47] this is also generally measured quite reliably. So, this is the wrist-based
[20:49] reliably. So, this is the wrist-based result with again, the Circa on the
[20:52] result with again, the Circa on the vertical axis and the reference along
[20:53] vertical axis and the reference along the horizontal axis.
[20:55] the horizontal axis. And most points are very close to the
[20:57] And most points are very close to the black line. So, it does seem that in the
[21:00] black line. So, it does seem that in the higher HRV range, that Garmin measures a
[21:03] higher HRV range, that Garmin measures a slightly lower HRV, but this could be an
[21:05] slightly lower HRV, but this could be an algorithmic difference. So, how they
[21:07] algorithmic difference. So, how they define their HRV. And the same is true
[21:10] define their HRV. And the same is true here on the biceps. We have basically
[21:13] here on the biceps. We have basically very similar results for on the wrist
[21:16] very similar results for on the wrist and the biceps. I just tested it on the
[21:18] and the biceps. I just tested it on the biceps quite a bit longer. And if we
[21:19] biceps quite a bit longer. And if we take a look at some example sessions, we
[21:22] take a look at some example sessions, we can indeed see that in the higher
[21:24] can indeed see that in the higher ranges, the reference is a little bit
[21:25] ranges, the reference is a little bit higher, but the overall patterns are
[21:28] higher, but the overall patterns are super similar both on the biceps and the
[21:31] super similar both on the biceps and the wrist. And I just have nothing to
[21:33] wrist. And I just have nothing to complain about here. So, overall, what
[21:36] complain about here. So, overall, what is my verdict on the Garmin Circa
[21:38] is my verdict on the Garmin Circa Smartband?
[21:40] Smartband? >> [music]
[21:40] >> [music] >> Well, I've really enjoyed using it. And
[21:42] >> Well, I've really enjoyed using it. And the one thing that actually makes a huge
[21:44] the one thing that actually makes a huge difference is that it has a button on
[21:46] difference is that it has a button on it. Now, this might seem small, but this
[21:48] it. Now, this might seem small, but this is a big quality of life improvement for
[21:50] is a big quality of life improvement for me because I can just start my exercise
[21:53] me because I can just start my exercise by clicking on the device and it will
[21:55] by clicking on the device and it will start. It gives a little green light.
[21:57] start. It gives a little green light. So, that's one downside of wearing it on
[21:59] So, that's one downside of wearing it on the biceps. If you have a long sleeve,
[22:00] the biceps. If you have a long sleeve, you cannot see if you started or stopped
[22:02] you cannot see if you started or stopped it. So, it will give a different pattern
[22:04] it. So, it will give a different pattern of
[22:05] of whether you start or stop it, but
[22:07] whether you start or stop it, but looking at the light is really the only
[22:08] looking at the light is really the only reliable way of knowing whether you're
[22:10] reliable way of knowing whether you're starting or stopping an exercise. So, I
[22:12] starting or stopping an exercise. So, I have accidentally let it run for a bit
[22:14] have accidentally let it run for a bit too long, but then I don't have to rely
[22:16] too long, but then I don't have to rely on the automatic activity detection,
[22:18] on the automatic activity detection, which has been a bit hit and miss for me
[22:21] which has been a bit hit and miss for me on the biceps especially, where it has
[22:23] on the biceps especially, where it has missed a bunch of exercises. Or when I
[22:25] missed a bunch of exercises. Or when I went on a long hike, for instance, none
[22:27] went on a long hike, for instance, none of that was tracked. So, having that
[22:29] of that was tracked. So, having that button is really good. The automatic
[22:31] button is really good. The automatic activity detection could be a bit
[22:33] activity detection could be a bit better, which is an extra reason to have
[22:35] better, which is an extra reason to have that button. I do hope while wearing it
[22:37] that button. I do hope while wearing it longer that Garmin learns how to
[22:39] longer that Garmin learns how to interpret my behavior basically and
[22:41] interpret my behavior basically and learns to classify that better over
[22:43] learns to classify that better over time.
[22:44] time. I decided to put a general cardio
[22:46] I decided to put a general cardio profile on that button, so you have to
[22:48] profile on that button, so you have to decide beforehand what is going to be
[22:50] decide beforehand what is going to be the profile that's going to be used when
[22:52] the profile that's going to be used when you click on that button. But it works
[22:54] you click on that button. But it works really well. I've had no complaints, no
[22:56] really well. I've had no complaints, no accidental presses either when worn on
[22:58] accidental presses either when worn on the wrist or on the biceps. And if we
[23:00] the wrist or on the biceps. And if we quickly summarize the testing results, I
[23:03] quickly summarize the testing results, I would say that the Garmin Circa both on
[23:05] would say that the Garmin Circa both on the wrist and the biceps is doing a
[23:07] the wrist and the biceps is doing a great job at tracking my heart rate and
[23:09] great job at tracking my heart rate and heart rate variability at night. The
[23:11] heart rate variability at night. The sleep stage tracking for some reason was
[23:13] sleep stage tracking for some reason was a good on my biceps, but only okay on
[23:16] a good on my biceps, but only okay on the wrist. And I would be curious to see
[23:18] the wrist. And I would be curious to see if this holds in the long run. And then
[23:20] if this holds in the long run. And then the heart rate tracking is only good on
[23:22] the heart rate tracking is only good on my wrist where it especially struggled
[23:24] my wrist where it especially struggled during running in my case, but on the
[23:27] during running in my case, but on the biceps is just great and I can
[23:28] biceps is just great and I can definitely recommend it. So, if you
[23:30] definitely recommend it. So, if you don't care too much about your sleep
[23:32] don't care too much about your sleep stages based on my testing at least, I
[23:34] stages based on my testing at least, I would say it's fine to wear your Garmin
[23:35] would say it's fine to wear your Garmin Circa on your wrist at night and then
[23:37] Circa on your wrist at night and then wear it on your biceps during exercise.
[23:40] wear it on your biceps during exercise. I wouldn't wear it on my wrist full-time
[23:42] I wouldn't wear it on my wrist full-time because it really cripples performance
[23:44] because it really cripples performance and you will likely get a lot better
[23:47] and you will likely get a lot better performance on your biceps. Now, these
[23:49] performance on your biceps. Now, these biceps bands at the moment aren't cheap
[23:51] biceps bands at the moment aren't cheap or easy to get. I hope third-party
[23:53] or easy to get. I hope third-party manufacturers will start to make them.
[23:55] manufacturers will start to make them. And also the sizing is a bit weird. So,
[23:57] And also the sizing is a bit weird. So, it's not a standard buckle, but quite a
[23:59] it's not a standard buckle, but quite a narrow attachment right here. So, I hope
[24:02] narrow attachment right here. So, I hope third-party manufacturers will start to
[24:05] third-party manufacturers will start to create Garmin Circas, but at least in
[24:07] create Garmin Circas, but at least in Austria at the moment, if you want
[24:08] Austria at the moment, if you want yourself an official biceps band, it
[24:11] yourself an official biceps band, it sets you back close to 60 bucks, whereas
[24:13] sets you back close to 60 bucks, whereas a whole Fitbit Air on your wrist then is
[24:16] a whole Fitbit Air on your wrist then is only 99 bucks. So, quite expensive and
[24:19] only 99 bucks. So, quite expensive and it usually takes quite a while to get
[24:21] it usually takes quite a while to get it. So, if I go for the larger version,
[24:23] it. So, if I go for the larger version, they only deliver in a couple of weeks.
[24:25] they only deliver in a couple of weeks. But still, I think it's worth to get
[24:27] But still, I think it's worth to get one. I think it's fine to wait for a bit
[24:29] one. I think it's fine to wait for a bit until Alex I start selling some. Or if
[24:32] until Alex I start selling some. Or if you're really keen on getting the best
[24:33] you're really keen on getting the best results, just bite the bullet and get
[24:35] results, just bite the bullet and get the expensive armbands.
[24:37] the expensive armbands. Overall though, I'm not disappointed
[24:39] Overall though, I'm not disappointed with the performance of the Circa and I
[24:41] with the performance of the Circa and I think it is a proper competitor to the
[24:44] think it is a proper competitor to the Fitbit Air, but also the Whoop strap and
[24:46] Fitbit Air, but also the Whoop strap and the Amazfit Helios strap. Now, it is
[24:48] the Amazfit Helios strap. Now, it is still on the more expensive side. Not
[24:50] still on the more expensive side. Not Whoop expensive, but for instance, the
[24:53] Whoop expensive, but for instance, the Amazfit Helios strap and the Fitbit Air
[24:55] Amazfit Helios strap and the Fitbit Air will only set you back 99 bucks and also
[24:58] will only set you back 99 bucks and also have really good performance. I'm
[24:59] have really good performance. I'm actually working on a dedicated review
[25:01] actually working on a dedicated review where I put the Garmin Circa and the
[25:03] where I put the Garmin Circa and the Fitbit Air side by side and there you
[25:06] Fitbit Air side by side and there you can really judge which is the right
[25:08] can really judge which is the right device for you. Now, in terms of app
[25:10] device for you. Now, in terms of app experience, what I do appreciate is the
[25:12] experience, what I do appreciate is the Garmin Circa works a lot better offline
[25:14] Garmin Circa works a lot better offline than the Fitbit Air did at least up till
[25:16] than the Fitbit Air did at least up till a while ago where the Fitbit Air just
[25:18] a while ago where the Fitbit Air just wouldn't sync exercises when you're not
[25:20] wouldn't sync exercises when you're not connected to the internet. That's at
[25:22] connected to the internet. That's at least how it was recently. Otherwise,
[25:24] least how it was recently. Otherwise, the Fitbit Air is also great option.
[25:26] the Fitbit Air is also great option. >> [music]
[25:26] >> [music] >> Now, if you do decide to get yourself a
[25:29] >> Now, if you do decide to get yourself a Garmin Circa, a Garmin Circa bicep band,
[25:31] Garmin Circa, a Garmin Circa bicep band, a Whoop strap, a nice little Helios
[25:34] a Whoop strap, a nice little Helios strap, an Ultrahuman Pro ring, an Oura
[25:36] strap, an Ultrahuman Pro ring, an Oura ring, another device or anything at all
[25:39] ring, another device or anything at all on Amazon for that matter, even
[25:41] on Amazon for that matter, even something as small as toilet paper or
[25:42] something as small as toilet paper or coffee beans, you want the best discount
[25:44] coffee beans, you want the best discount possible and to support the channel,
[25:46] possible and to support the channel, there's different affiliate links down
[25:48] there's different affiliate links down in the description below, many of which
[25:49] in the description below, many of which give you the best discount possible.
[25:52] give you the best discount possible. Now, don't forget to like and subscribe
[25:54] Now, don't forget to like and subscribe and also watch this video on the Fitbit
[25:56] and also watch this video on the Fitbit Air and this video on the Eight Sleep
[25:59] Air and this video on the Eight Sleep Pod.
[26:01] Pod. >> [music]
All frames
Total: 52. Hero frames flagged with star.
frames/frame_0001.jpg(t=00:00)frames/frame_0002.jpg(t=00:07)frames/frame_0003.jpg(t=00:09)frames/frame_0004.jpg(t=00:10)frames/frame_0005.jpg(t=00:11)frames/frame_0006.jpg(t=00:32)frames/frame_0007.jpg(t=00:45)frames/frame_0008.jpg(t=00:50)frames/frame_0009.jpg(t=00:58)frames/frame_0010.jpg(t=01:06)frames/frame_0011.jpg(t=01:18)frames/frame_0012.jpg(t=01:24)frames/frame_0013.jpg(t=01:31)frames/frame_0014.jpg(t=01:34)frames/frame_0015.jpg(t=01:49)frames/frame_0016.jpg(t=10:26)frames/frame_0017.jpg(t=10:33)frames/frame_0018.jpg(t=10:44)frames/frame_0019.jpg(t=10:46)frames/frame_0020.jpg(t=10:47)frames/frame_0021.jpg(t=10:59)frames/frame_0022.jpg(t=11:00)frames/frame_0023.jpg(t=11:02)frames/frame_0024.jpg(t=11:04)frames/frame_0025.jpg(t=11:06)frames/frame_0026.jpg(t=11:22)frames/frame_0027.jpg(t=11:31)frames/frame_0028.jpg(t=11:35)frames/frame_0029.jpg(t=11:41)frames/frame_0030.jpg(t=13:02)frames/frame_0031.jpg(t=16:46)frames/frame_0032.jpg(t=17:41)frames/frame_0033.jpg(t=18:24)frames/frame_0034.jpg(t=18:27)frames/frame_0035.jpg(t=18:29)frames/frame_0036.jpg(t=18:34)frames/frame_0037.jpg(t=18:37)frames/frame_0038.jpg(t=18:40)frames/frame_0039.jpg(t=21:35)frames/frame_0040.jpg(t=23:00)frames/frame_0041.jpg(t=23:49)frames/frame_0042.jpg(t=23:57)frames/frame_0043.jpg(t=24:02)frames/frame_0044.jpg(t=24:06)frames/frame_0045.jpg(t=24:25)frames/frame_0046.jpg(t=25:32)frames/frame_0047.jpg(t=25:33)frames/frame_0048.jpg(t=25:36)frames/frame_0049.jpg(t=25:37)frames/frame_0050.jpg(t=25:40)frames/frame_0051.jpg(t=25:43)frames/frame_0052.jpg(t=26:00)